P.L. Simmonds, the author of "The Millets, or Small Seeded Food Grains," had two decades earlier written about millets in a less expanded form, except for fonio, to which he gave a longer treatment worth noting. This was on pages 310-311 in his 1854 The Commercial Products of the Vegetable Kingdom (London, T. F. A. Day). The section is entitled "Fundi or fundungi," https://archive.org/details/commercialproduc00simm_0/page/310/mode/2up (if you page back, you'll see discussion of other millets). He was clearly enthusiastic about fonio, referring to it as "this delicious grain," and writing about several ways it was consumed in West Africa, as well as about its cultivation. Simmonds was far from the first foreigner to describe fonio or ways that it is cooked and eaten (one could go back 5 centuries to Ibn Battuta, for example), but what was notable was a suggestion that seems prescient in hindsight: "This grain could be raised in sufficient quantities to become an article of commerce and an addition to the light farinaceous articles of food..." What he was apparently not clued in about was the labor-intensive process of processing fonio - especially dehulling it, which has been discussed on Collab in the past. Small scale mechanization, including locally engineered and produced dehullers, have over the last three decades facilitated the larger production that is supplying local demand and growing export potential. The rise of fonio to international attention - including in North America - is a recent and remarkable story that of course has nothing to do with anyone's predictions 170 years ago ago. But I thought it was interesting to note that SImmonds saw in it this potential long before most people did. In his 1877 book section on millets, Simmonds toned down the attention given to this grain to a single sentence under a different, supposedly related grain (koto milllet). No information on what the story is behind that. Was there pushback over the intervening years on his initial enthusiasm for fonio? A final item of possible interest on P.L. Simmonds. Among his diverse areas of work, according to Pierre Desrochers, was promotion in the UK of the idea that "increased profitability and a cleaner environment go hand in hand." ("Victorian Pioneers of Corporate Sustainability," The Business History Review 83(4):703-729 April 2011 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/254419554_Victorian_Pioneers_of_Cor... ) DO, EL, MI, US NAMA On Thu, Oct 29, 2026 at 10:38 AM Don Osborn <don@milletsalliance.org> wrote:
While tracking down details of the history of kodo millet in North America, I came across an 1877 description of millets, including kodo (spelled "koda"), that gives another window into how these grains were understood in the 19th century. It appears as a section entitled "The Millets, or Small Seeded Food Grains" (pp. 335-342) in the book :
P.L. (Peter Lund) Simmonds, 1877, Tropical agriculture: a treatise on the culture, preparation, commerce and consumption of the principal products of the vegetable kingdom, London; New York : E. & F.N. Spon.
The book can be read online at the following websites (links are to the first page of the section): * https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=wu.89047173380&seq=355 * https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.55509/page/335/mode/2up * https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Tropical_agriculture._A... * https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=hvd.32044107228025&seq=352 (1889 ed.) * https://archive.org/details/tropicalagricul00simmgoog/page/335/mode/2up (1889 ed.)
In February and March 1879, The Florida Agriculturist (a newspaper published for over 30 years in DeLand, FL) serialized this section as a sequence of 4 articles under the same title used by Simmonds in his book. For the first of these in Issue 40, Feb. 19, 1879, page 6 (page 308), see the following links: * https://ufdc.ufl.edu/UF00047911/00652/images/5 * https://www.newspapers.com/image/863614945/
After a brief intro to the topic, Simmonds spends a good deal of time on varieties of sorghum, before considering various other millets. As you read, you'll be navigating older and current botanical names and a variety of common names, some of which I've never heard of.
For fun, I put together an online matching game, where you pair Simmonds terms (other than for sorghum) with the currently accepted botanical names. Some are easy, othes you may have to look up in the above book section: https://puzzel.org/en/matching-pairs/play?p=-P56yLZ6rrNL8tL0ZS0_
Don Osborn, PhD (East Lansing, MI, US) North American Millets Alliance