Re: Quiz: Identify 2 millets in 2 images
by Don Osborn
PS- Offlist, Gary guessed browntop correctly.
PPS- I would not use the adjective "nutty" to describe the taste of either
barnyard or browntop.
DO, EL, MI, US
NAMA
On Fri, Jun 19, 2026 at 12:12 PM Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org> wrote:
> The two millets are barnyard millet on the left, and browntop on the
> right. Attached is the same image of the uncooked grains that I shared
> earlier. (In that original email, the links were duds, but the attachments
> worked.)
>
> The barnyard millet (which being from India I assume is Echinochloa
> frumentacea, but might be E. esculenta) is from only my second purchase
> (this one under tha brand name Manna). My first use of it was only 2-3
> years ago.
>
> The browntop was my first ever purchase (under the Danodia Organic label).
> I had never tried it before this year.- it's harder to find.
>
> Both have grains about the size of proso or kodo. They were cooked in a
> small rice cooker, with a water to grain proportion of about 2.5 : 1.
>
> Comparing the taste of barnyard and browntop, I found the former to have a
> pleasantly flat or bland taste, but a slight "earthy" aftertaste that I
> noticed in the olfactory sense. No bitterness or anything offputting.
> Definitely will try again, but will seek another brand, preferably organic.
>
> The browntop (Uruchloa or Brachiaria ramosa), on the other hand, had other
> subtle notes (such as rice, but not the same), and neither aftertaste nor
> bitterness. The latter seems significant in that one report on browntop's
> closest cultivated relative, Guinea millet (U./B. deflexa) was that people
> found the grain bitter.
>
> (One note regarding perception of bitterness in foods: my tastebuds may be
> unusual in that I like foods such as bitter melon and baobab leaf sauce.)
>
> It would be interesting to try both of these from domestic sources,
> although since varieties in this part of the world are not intended for
> harvest as food grains, I'm not sure what to expect in terms of size or
> characteristics of grains.
>
> Notes on names:
> 1. Barnyard millet is the catch-all term in international use for the 2
> main cultivated Echinochloa spp.: E. esculenta (Japanese barnyard millet or
> in the US usually Japanese millet) and E. frumentacea (Indian barnyard
> millet, and in the US often, billion dollar grass).
> 2. Browntop millet is also called in the US, Dixie signalgrass. A variety
> of this that we recently discussed on this list is called Chiwapa millet.
>
> Don
>
> DO, EL, MI, US
> NAMA
>
>
> On Sun, Jun 14, 2026 at 9:25 AM Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
> wrote:
>
>> Here is another comparison related to the previously shown millets.
>> First, however, I apologize for the links in the middle of the previous
>> email that were the result of my attempt to move the images in-line wth the
>> text. Please access the attachments and ignore the inline links.
>>
>> Attached is a composite image of the water in which each of these millets
>> was soaked. It is my practice to rinse whole grains before cooking, and in
>> the case of millets also to soak them for a period of time (usually
>> overnight or morning to evening). I then dump that into a strainer and
>> rinse again before the actual cooking.
>>
>> In the case of each of these two millets, I saved the soaking water since
>> the difference was so striking. This might not help in identifying the
>> millets, but still might be interesting. I've retained the same "left -
>> right" tags for reference.
>>
>> DO, EL, MI, US
>> NAMA
>>
>>
>> On Sat, Jun 13, 2026 at 10:28 PM Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
>> wrote:
>>
>>> This is a hard one. Here are images of the grain of two millets, side
>>> by side. These are small (minor) millets, imported from India. What are
>>> they?
>>>
>>> The first image shows the hulled grains, uncooked.
>>>
>>> The second image shows the cooked grains.
>>>
>>> These images are at 20%. They occupy the same left-right positions in
>>> both images. If anyone wants to look more closely I can send the full sized
>>> ones.
>>>
>>> I mentioned these two recently to Joni and Gary, but they have not seen
>>> the images yet. Nevertheless, if they want to respond, please allow a
>>> little time in case others have guesses.
>>>
>>> Later I'll offer some comments on my personal taste tests of the two.
>>>
>>> Don
>>>
>>> Don Osborn, PhD
>>> (East Lansing, MI, US)
>>> North American Millets Alliance
>>>
>>
5 months
Re: [Collab] Reply to WSJ article on "millet" having "no taste"
by Don Osborn
Thank you for your replies,
Joni, the article does seem to be an outlier, which is not to suggest that
all coverage on millets has to be the same or uniformly positive. But here
I get the sense that the object was to find some catchy juxtaposition (per
clickbait, as you put it). It missed on some fundamentals, as I see it -
namely: omission of mention of the International Year of Millets; no a
clear indication that the authors understood that "millet" is not one
thing, culinarily; and no delving into the premise of "no taste." A more
productive angle, if they wanted to focus on the matter of flavors of
millets, might have been to ask if taste might be a factor in the decline
of popularity of millets relative to major cereal grains in India (since
that country was the setting for the effort we are reviewing), and if it
might be a factor in their revival. Not sure that would have worked either,
but it might have been more thought provoking.
This short feature article does not seem to have had much play in any media
space, so it may not be helpful to write a formal reply. On the other hand,
it might be worth cultivating relations with food writers at the WSJ and
other news organizations. It's good that millets (even if just "millet")
got some recognition in this paper - has it run any straight news pieces on
millets or the IYM?. Maybe an invitation rather than a rebuttal would yield
a better harvest?
David, I actually have a waxy (glutinous [not glutEn as we know], or
"sticky") proso millet in my kitchen. I've only used it as a grain
component in a stew, with the thought that its physical qualities help make
the sauce part more viscous (I'm more of a food hacker than a cook, but the
resulta aren;t bad. My impression generally is that the flavor isn't
significantly different. In the case of rice, for me, sticky rice is
comfortably in the range of rice flavors. If you have a market specializing
in Chinese foods, it should be easy to find sticky ("nuo") millets: proso
("da-hwang-mi") or foxtail ("xiao-mi").
Regarding flavors of millets generally, I'd still like to see some "blind"
taste tests. Is there enough of a millets constituency at Iowa State to
arrange such a thing, say this fall?
Best to all,
Don
DO, EL, MI, US
NAMA
On Mon, Mar 25, 2024 at 11:29 AM Brenner, David (CTR) - REE-ARS <
david.brenner(a)usda.gov> wrote:
> If this were a taste race with rice some millets could win placing near
> bulgar wheat. I would like to enter waxy versions of millets in the same
> race, but I have never tasted them, so I just guess they are wonderful.
> Cooks make whole-plate compositions, as Don says. For example, we still
> have vanilla ice cream even though chocolate ice cream and sherbert are
> available. David Brenner
>
> ------------------------------
> *From:* Collab <collab-bounces(a)lists.millets2023.space> on behalf of Joni
> Kindwall-Moore <joni(a)snacktivistfoods.com>
> *Sent:* Monday, March 25, 2024 9:30 AM
> *To:* Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
> *Cc:* collab(a)lists.millets2023.space <collab(a)lists.millets2023.space>
> *Subject:* [External Email]Re: [Collab] Reply to WSJ article on "millet"
> having "no taste"
>
> [External Email]
> If this message comes from an *unexpected sender* or references a *vague/unexpected
> topic;*
> Use caution before clicking links or opening attachments.
> Please send any concerns or suspicious messages to: Spam.Abuse(a)usda.gov
> Yes, it was clear that it was just a 'click bait' silly article for the
> reasons you mentioned above Don. What a wasted of journalism space. We
> should write a rebuttal and approach the WSJ with it.
>
> On Sun, Mar 24, 2024 at 8:04 PM Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
> wrote:
>
> Here is my reply to the Wall Street Journal article that characterised
> "millet" as a "superfood" with "no taste." Thank you again to Prof. Dipak
> Santra for enabling us to access the full article. Thanks also to Gary
> Wietgrefe for his take on this issue, which I used in the third ("So
> what?") question I raised. This was posted to LinkedIn on Friday 3/22. DO
>
>
> The Wall Street Journal ran a feature article last fall that was less than
> favorable about hashtag#millets from the perspective of hashtag#flavor -
> "It’s the World’s Hot New Superfood. The Snag: It ‘Has No Taste.’"*
> Although the authors cover some useful points - and one is never upset to
> see more discussion about millets - I'd like to engage with the premise of
> "no taste." To do so I'll pose three questions: What are we talking about?
> What are we expecting? & So what?
>
> First, however, wanted to express surprise that no reference was made in
> the article to the larger context of Indian P.M. Narenda Modi's interest in
> these grains, namely, the International Year of Millets (2023). How could
> the authors and the WSJ editors fail to mention this observance, the
> promotion of which has been a major project of P.M. Modi's government, and
> which was ongoing at the time of publication?
>
> My three questions about the article's premise that millets have no taste,
> and thoughts about them, follow:
> 1. What are we talking about? The article is one of those which uses the
> singular "millet" throughout, and this generally raises the question of
> whether the authors are referring to (a) one specific kind of millet, being
> unaware of other kinds, or rather (b) all kinds of millets, seen as having
> the same characteristics. In this case, I'll assume that the authors (Shan
> Li and Rajesh Roy) are aware of the plurality of millets, but for whatever
> reason, treat them as so similar as to present as one thing in foods (b).
>
> In fact, millets are not the same. Personally I found this out years ago
> when buying one "millet" thinking it was another, and finding out that the
> taste was totally different. Today, some millets like proso and fonio are
> described as having a slightly "nutty" flavor (this adjective is admittedly
> overused), although I've also seen proso once compared to roasted corn (not
> sure I'd agree, but it's clearly not without taste). Others, like little,
> kodo, barnyard, are flatter in taste, closer to rice. One author described
> finger millet as having a chocolatey flavor. Pearl millet has yet another
> flavor, which I find unique.
>
> 2. What are we expecting? Grains in general have subtle flavors, and
> millets are no exception. They bring notes and textures to a dish or
> confection, as well as bulk (esp. in high-starch diets), but aren't there
> to dominate. Even bread, typically built around wheat flour, includes a few
> or even many other ingredients - and then is eaten as a side or with a
> spread.
>
> 3. So what if they did have "no taste"? Who normally eats a grain without
> accompaniment of some sort? Even if a millet is perceived as being bland,
> I'd argue that the issue is what combinations work best with it. Food
> cultures of Asia and Africa may be well-established in this respect, but
> there is opportunity to experiment further everywhere - and that's the key
> message I'd propose at this point.
>
> * WSJ, 20 Oct 2023
> https://www.wsj.com/world/asia/supergrain-millet-healthy-india-modi-2cc8b9d4
>
>
> Don Osborn, PhD
> (East Lansing, MI, US)
> North American Millets Alliance
>
>
> --
> Collab mailing list
> Collab(a)lists.millets2023.space
> https://lists.millets2023.space/mailman/listinfo/collab
>
>
>
>
>
> This electronic message contains information generated by the USDA solely
> for the intended recipients. Any unauthorized interception of this message
> or the use or disclosure of the information it contains may violate the law
> and subject the violator to civil or criminal penalties. If you believe you
> have received this message in error, please notify the sender and delete
> the email immediately.
>
2 years, 7 months
Re: [Collab] Collab Digest, Vol 26, Issue 6
by Gary Wietgrefe
Don, I appreciated your reply to the WSJ. Ignoring the article would
confirm the premise.
As David suggested, millet is a rice alternative, just like bulgar wheat.
When millet reaches the U.S. food market share of bulgar wheat, millet
needs to step up to the share of pearl barley, rye (breads), oats (rolled,
meal, milk), then millet would be on its way to reaching the share of durum
wheat, and etcetera...just like other grains are trying to get to millet's
market share of wild birdfeed.
Today's closing ceremony of International Year of Millets proved increased
awareness of millets worldwide with speakers from Algeria, Australia, and
Minnesota, plus the expected substantial representation of India and
central Africa. It didn't just happen. India and the U.N. took the lead
highlighting millet uses through news media.
As suggested with waxy, someone, likely this group, needs to take the lead
with U.S. millet news articles. It is not enough to just respond when some
entity, as unlikely as the WSJ, randomly gives millet a bit of
recognition....Gary Wietgrefe
On Fri, Mar 29, 2024 at 6:01 AM <collab-request(a)lists.millets2023.space>
wrote:
> Send Collab mailing list submissions to
> collab(a)lists.millets2023.space
>
> To subscribe or unsubscribe via the World Wide Web, visit
> https://lists.millets2023.space/mailman/listinfo/collab
> or, via email, send a message with subject or body 'help' to
> collab-request(a)lists.millets2023.space
>
> You can reach the person managing the list at
> collab-owner(a)lists.millets2023.space
>
> When replying, please edit your Subject line so it is more specific
> than "Re: Contents of Collab digest..."
>
>
> Today's Topics:
>
> 1. Re: Reply to WSJ article on "millet" having "no taste"
> (Don Osborn)
>
>
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Message: 1
> Date: Thu, 28 Mar 2024 09:06:41 -0400
> From: Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
> To: "Brenner, David (CTR) - REE-ARS" <david.brenner(a)usda.gov>
> Cc: Joni Kindwall-Moore <joni(a)snacktivistfoods.com>,
> "collab(a)lists.millets2023.space" <collab(a)lists.millets2023.space>
> Subject: Re: [Collab] Reply to WSJ article on "millet" having "no
> taste"
> Message-ID:
> <CA+RHibXPTUq=
> jwGGkyV9a3a2R1b2yS4xkmWJpkAAA21iXHuLqQ(a)mail.gmail.com>
> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
>
> Thank you for your replies,
>
> Joni, the article does seem to be an outlier, which is not to suggest that
> all coverage on millets has to be the same or uniformly positive. But here
> I get the sense that the object was to find some catchy juxtaposition (per
> clickbait, as you put it). It missed on some fundamentals, as I see it -
> namely: omission of mention of the International Year of Millets; no a
> clear indication that the authors understood that "millet" is not one
> thing, culinarily; and no delving into the premise of "no taste." A more
> productive angle, if they wanted to focus on the matter of flavors of
> millets, might have been to ask if taste might be a factor in the decline
> of popularity of millets relative to major cereal grains in India (since
> that country was the setting for the effort we are reviewing), and if it
> might be a factor in their revival. Not sure that would have worked either,
> but it might have been more thought provoking.
>
> This short feature article does not seem to have had much play in any media
> space, so it may not be helpful to write a formal reply. On the other hand,
> it might be worth cultivating relations with food writers at the WSJ and
> other news organizations. It's good that millets (even if just "millet")
> got some recognition in this paper - has it run any straight news pieces on
> millets or the IYM?. Maybe an invitation rather than a rebuttal would yield
> a better harvest?
>
> David, I actually have a waxy (glutinous [not glutEn as we know], or
> "sticky") proso millet in my kitchen. I've only used it as a grain
> component in a stew, with the thought that its physical qualities help make
> the sauce part more viscous (I'm more of a food hacker than a cook, but the
> resulta aren;t bad. My impression generally is that the flavor isn't
> significantly different. In the case of rice, for me, sticky rice is
> comfortably in the range of rice flavors. If you have a market specializing
> in Chinese foods, it should be easy to find sticky ("nuo") millets: proso
> ("da-hwang-mi") or foxtail ("xiao-mi").
>
> Regarding flavors of millets generally, I'd still like to see some "blind"
> taste tests. Is there enough of a millets constituency at Iowa State to
> arrange such a thing, say this fall?
>
> Best to all,
>
> Don
>
> DO, EL, MI, US
> NAMA
>
>
> On Mon, Mar 25, 2024 at 11:29?AM Brenner, David (CTR) - REE-ARS <
> david.brenner(a)usda.gov> wrote:
>
> > If this were a taste race with rice some millets could win placing near
> > bulgar wheat. I would like to enter waxy versions of millets in the same
> > race, but I have never tasted them, so I just guess they are wonderful.
> > Cooks make whole-plate compositions, as Don says. For example, we still
> > have vanilla ice cream even though chocolate ice cream and sherbert are
> > available. David Brenner
> >
> > ------------------------------
> > *From:* Collab <collab-bounces(a)lists.millets2023.space> on behalf of
> Joni
> > Kindwall-Moore <joni(a)snacktivistfoods.com>
> > *Sent:* Monday, March 25, 2024 9:30 AM
> > *To:* Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
> > *Cc:* collab(a)lists.millets2023.space <collab(a)lists.millets2023.space>
> > *Subject:* [External Email]Re: [Collab] Reply to WSJ article on "millet"
> > having "no taste"
> >
> > [External Email]
> > If this message comes from an *unexpected sender* or references a
> *vague/unexpected
> > topic;*
> > Use caution before clicking links or opening attachments.
> > Please send any concerns or suspicious messages to: Spam.Abuse(a)usda.gov
> > Yes, it was clear that it was just a 'click bait' silly article for the
> > reasons you mentioned above Don. What a wasted of journalism space. We
> > should write a rebuttal and approach the WSJ with it.
> >
> > On Sun, Mar 24, 2024 at 8:04?PM Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
> > wrote:
> >
> > Here is my reply to the Wall Street Journal article that characterised
> > "millet" as a "superfood" with "no taste." Thank you again to Prof.
> Dipak
> > Santra for enabling us to access the full article. Thanks also to Gary
> > Wietgrefe for his take on this issue, which I used in the third ("So
> > what?") question I raised. This was posted to LinkedIn on Friday 3/22.
> DO
> >
> >
> > The Wall Street Journal ran a feature article last fall that was less
> than
> > favorable about hashtag#millets from the perspective of hashtag#flavor -
> > "It?s the World?s Hot New Superfood. The Snag: It ?Has No Taste.?"*
> > Although the authors cover some useful points - and one is never upset to
> > see more discussion about millets - I'd like to engage with the premise
> of
> > "no taste." To do so I'll pose three questions: What are we talking
> about?
> > What are we expecting? & So what?
> >
> > First, however, wanted to express surprise that no reference was made in
> > the article to the larger context of Indian P.M. Narenda Modi's interest
> in
> > these grains, namely, the International Year of Millets (2023). How could
> > the authors and the WSJ editors fail to mention this observance, the
> > promotion of which has been a major project of P.M. Modi's government,
> and
> > which was ongoing at the time of publication?
> >
> > My three questions about the article's premise that millets have no
> taste,
> > and thoughts about them, follow:
> > 1. What are we talking about? The article is one of those which uses the
> > singular "millet" throughout, and this generally raises the question of
> > whether the authors are referring to (a) one specific kind of millet,
> being
> > unaware of other kinds, or rather (b) all kinds of millets, seen as
> having
> > the same characteristics. In this case, I'll assume that the authors
> (Shan
> > Li and Rajesh Roy) are aware of the plurality of millets, but for
> whatever
> > reason, treat them as so similar as to present as one thing in foods (b).
> >
> > In fact, millets are not the same. Personally I found this out years ago
> > when buying one "millet" thinking it was another, and finding out that
> the
> > taste was totally different. Today, some millets like proso and fonio are
> > described as having a slightly "nutty" flavor (this adjective is
> admittedly
> > overused), although I've also seen proso once compared to roasted corn
> (not
> > sure I'd agree, but it's clearly not without taste). Others, like little,
> > kodo, barnyard, are flatter in taste, closer to rice. One author
> described
> > finger millet as having a chocolatey flavor. Pearl millet has yet another
> > flavor, which I find unique.
> >
> > 2. What are we expecting? Grains in general have subtle flavors, and
> > millets are no exception. They bring notes and textures to a dish or
> > confection, as well as bulk (esp. in high-starch diets), but aren't there
> > to dominate. Even bread, typically built around wheat flour, includes a
> few
> > or even many other ingredients - and then is eaten as a side or with a
> > spread.
> >
> > 3. So what if they did have "no taste"? Who normally eats a grain without
> > accompaniment of some sort? Even if a millet is perceived as being bland,
> > I'd argue that the issue is what combinations work best with it. Food
> > cultures of Asia and Africa may be well-established in this respect, but
> > there is opportunity to experiment further everywhere - and that's the
> key
> > message I'd propose at this point.
> >
> > * WSJ, 20 Oct 2023
> >
> https://www.wsj.com/world/asia/supergrain-millet-healthy-india-modi-2cc8b9d4
> >
> >
> > Don Osborn, PhD
> > (East Lansing, MI, US)
> > North American Millets Alliance
> >
> >
> > --
> > Collab mailing list
> > Collab(a)lists.millets2023.space
> > https://lists.millets2023.space/mailman/listinfo/collab
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > This electronic message contains information generated by the USDA solely
> > for the intended recipients. Any unauthorized interception of this
> message
> > or the use or disclosure of the information it contains may violate the
> law
> > and subject the violator to civil or criminal penalties. If you believe
> you
> > have received this message in error, please notify the sender and delete
> > the email immediately.
> >
>
2 years, 7 months
Re: [Collab] Collab Digest, Vol 26, Issue 6
by Joni Kindwall-Moore
Gary,
Great thoughts!
I have been in communication with Leon Kreisel who grows waxy Proso (thanks
for connecting us Dr Santra).
He has waxy Proso available right now, I would love to bring it to market
but I literally can’t even get it hulled to do initial product dev on it
due to the lack of processing. This remains the biggest barrier to growing
domestic markets for diverse small cereals like millets thus preventing
development of innovation.
I’ve just secured a grant along with our partners at Zego foods and we will
be installing millet processing to open up this bottleneck.
https://snacktivistfoods.com/blogs/news/usda-awards-snacktivist-and-zego-3m…
Waxy proso may also be a fantastic IQF grain to be mixed in with rice for
foodservice etc.
thanks
*Joni Kindwall-Moore BSN-RN, BA*
Founder, Innovator, Mother, Nurse, Activist
*P: 406-334-1608* *www.snacktivistfoods.com
<http://www.snacktivistfoods.com/>*
*Scan this QR code to experience the Snacktivist Nation! *
On Fri, Mar 29, 2024 at 8:23 AM Gary Wietgrefe via Collab <
collab(a)lists.millets2023.space> wrote:
> Don, I appreciated your reply to the WSJ. Ignoring the article would
> confirm the premise.
> As David suggested, millet is a rice alternative, just like bulgar wheat.
> When millet reaches the U.S. food market share of bulgar wheat, millet
> needs to step up to the share of pearl barley, rye (breads), oats (rolled,
> meal, milk), then millet would be on its way to reaching the share of durum
> wheat, and etcetera...just like other grains are trying to get to millet's
> market share of wild birdfeed.
> Today's closing ceremony of International Year of Millets proved increased
> awareness of millets worldwide with speakers from Algeria, Australia, and
> Minnesota, plus the expected substantial representation of India and
> central Africa. It didn't just happen. India and the U.N. took the lead
> highlighting millet uses through news media.
> As suggested with waxy, someone, likely this group, needs to take the lead
> with U.S. millet news articles. It is not enough to just respond when some
> entity, as unlikely as the WSJ, randomly gives millet a bit of
> recognition....Gary Wietgrefe
>
> On Fri, Mar 29, 2024 at 6:01 AM <collab-request(a)lists.millets2023.space>
> wrote:
>
>> Send Collab mailing list submissions to
>> collab(a)lists.millets2023.space
>>
>> To subscribe or unsubscribe via the World Wide Web, visit
>> https://lists.millets2023.space/mailman/listinfo/collab
>> or, via email, send a message with subject or body 'help' to
>> collab-request(a)lists.millets2023.space
>>
>> You can reach the person managing the list at
>> collab-owner(a)lists.millets2023.space
>>
>> When replying, please edit your Subject line so it is more specific
>> than "Re: Contents of Collab digest..."
>>
>>
>> Today's Topics:
>>
>> 1. Re: Reply to WSJ article on "millet" having "no taste"
>> (Don Osborn)
>>
>>
>> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>> Message: 1
>> Date: Thu, 28 Mar 2024 09:06:41 -0400
>> From: Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
>> To: "Brenner, David (CTR) - REE-ARS" <david.brenner(a)usda.gov>
>> Cc: Joni Kindwall-Moore <joni(a)snacktivistfoods.com>,
>> "collab(a)lists.millets2023.space" <collab(a)lists.millets2023.space>
>> Subject: Re: [Collab] Reply to WSJ article on "millet" having "no
>> taste"
>> Message-ID:
>> <CA+RHibXPTUq=
>> jwGGkyV9a3a2R1b2yS4xkmWJpkAAA21iXHuLqQ(a)mail.gmail.com>
>> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
>>
>> Thank you for your replies,
>>
>> Joni, the article does seem to be an outlier, which is not to suggest that
>> all coverage on millets has to be the same or uniformly positive. But here
>> I get the sense that the object was to find some catchy juxtaposition (per
>> clickbait, as you put it). It missed on some fundamentals, as I see it -
>> namely: omission of mention of the International Year of Millets; no a
>> clear indication that the authors understood that "millet" is not one
>> thing, culinarily; and no delving into the premise of "no taste." A more
>> productive angle, if they wanted to focus on the matter of flavors of
>> millets, might have been to ask if taste might be a factor in the decline
>> of popularity of millets relative to major cereal grains in India (since
>> that country was the setting for the effort we are reviewing), and if it
>> might be a factor in their revival. Not sure that would have worked
>> either,
>> but it might have been more thought provoking.
>>
>> This short feature article does not seem to have had much play in any
>> media
>> space, so it may not be helpful to write a formal reply. On the other
>> hand,
>> it might be worth cultivating relations with food writers at the WSJ and
>> other news organizations. It's good that millets (even if just "millet")
>> got some recognition in this paper - has it run any straight news pieces
>> on
>> millets or the IYM?. Maybe an invitation rather than a rebuttal would
>> yield
>> a better harvest?
>>
>> David, I actually have a waxy (glutinous [not glutEn as we know], or
>> "sticky") proso millet in my kitchen. I've only used it as a grain
>> component in a stew, with the thought that its physical qualities help
>> make
>> the sauce part more viscous (I'm more of a food hacker than a cook, but
>> the
>> resulta aren;t bad. My impression generally is that the flavor isn't
>> significantly different. In the case of rice, for me, sticky rice is
>> comfortably in the range of rice flavors. If you have a market
>> specializing
>> in Chinese foods, it should be easy to find sticky ("nuo") millets: proso
>> ("da-hwang-mi") or foxtail ("xiao-mi").
>>
>> Regarding flavors of millets generally, I'd still like to see some "blind"
>> taste tests. Is there enough of a millets constituency at Iowa State to
>> arrange such a thing, say this fall?
>>
>> Best to all,
>>
>> Don
>>
>> DO, EL, MI, US
>> NAMA
>>
>>
>> On Mon, Mar 25, 2024 at 11:29?AM Brenner, David (CTR) - REE-ARS <
>> david.brenner(a)usda.gov> wrote:
>>
>> > If this were a taste race with rice some millets could win placing near
>> > bulgar wheat. I would like to enter waxy versions of millets in the
>> same
>> > race, but I have never tasted them, so I just guess they are wonderful.
>> > Cooks make whole-plate compositions, as Don says. For example, we still
>> > have vanilla ice cream even though chocolate ice cream and sherbert are
>> > available. David Brenner
>> >
>> > ------------------------------
>> > *From:* Collab <collab-bounces(a)lists.millets2023.space> on behalf of
>> Joni
>> > Kindwall-Moore <joni(a)snacktivistfoods.com>
>> > *Sent:* Monday, March 25, 2024 9:30 AM
>> > *To:* Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
>> > *Cc:* collab(a)lists.millets2023.space <collab(a)lists.millets2023.space>
>> > *Subject:* [External Email]Re: [Collab] Reply to WSJ article on "millet"
>> > having "no taste"
>> >
>> > [External Email]
>> > If this message comes from an *unexpected sender* or references a
>> *vague/unexpected
>> > topic;*
>> > Use caution before clicking links or opening attachments.
>> > Please send any concerns or suspicious messages to: Spam.Abuse(a)usda.gov
>> > Yes, it was clear that it was just a 'click bait' silly article for the
>> > reasons you mentioned above Don. What a wasted of journalism space. We
>> > should write a rebuttal and approach the WSJ with it.
>> >
>> > On Sun, Mar 24, 2024 at 8:04?PM Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
>> > wrote:
>> >
>> > Here is my reply to the Wall Street Journal article that characterised
>> > "millet" as a "superfood" with "no taste." Thank you again to Prof.
>> Dipak
>> > Santra for enabling us to access the full article. Thanks also to Gary
>> > Wietgrefe for his take on this issue, which I used in the third ("So
>> > what?") question I raised. This was posted to LinkedIn on Friday 3/22.
>> DO
>> >
>> >
>> > The Wall Street Journal ran a feature article last fall that was less
>> than
>> > favorable about hashtag#millets from the perspective of hashtag#flavor -
>> > "It?s the World?s Hot New Superfood. The Snag: It ?Has No Taste.?"*
>> > Although the authors cover some useful points - and one is never upset
>> to
>> > see more discussion about millets - I'd like to engage with the premise
>> of
>> > "no taste." To do so I'll pose three questions: What are we talking
>> about?
>> > What are we expecting? & So what?
>> >
>> > First, however, wanted to express surprise that no reference was made in
>> > the article to the larger context of Indian P.M. Narenda Modi's
>> interest in
>> > these grains, namely, the International Year of Millets (2023). How
>> could
>> > the authors and the WSJ editors fail to mention this observance, the
>> > promotion of which has been a major project of P.M. Modi's government,
>> and
>> > which was ongoing at the time of publication?
>> >
>> > My three questions about the article's premise that millets have no
>> taste,
>> > and thoughts about them, follow:
>> > 1. What are we talking about? The article is one of those which uses the
>> > singular "millet" throughout, and this generally raises the question of
>> > whether the authors are referring to (a) one specific kind of millet,
>> being
>> > unaware of other kinds, or rather (b) all kinds of millets, seen as
>> having
>> > the same characteristics. In this case, I'll assume that the authors
>> (Shan
>> > Li and Rajesh Roy) are aware of the plurality of millets, but for
>> whatever
>> > reason, treat them as so similar as to present as one thing in foods
>> (b).
>> >
>> > In fact, millets are not the same. Personally I found this out years ago
>> > when buying one "millet" thinking it was another, and finding out that
>> the
>> > taste was totally different. Today, some millets like proso and fonio
>> are
>> > described as having a slightly "nutty" flavor (this adjective is
>> admittedly
>> > overused), although I've also seen proso once compared to roasted corn
>> (not
>> > sure I'd agree, but it's clearly not without taste). Others, like
>> little,
>> > kodo, barnyard, are flatter in taste, closer to rice. One author
>> described
>> > finger millet as having a chocolatey flavor. Pearl millet has yet
>> another
>> > flavor, which I find unique.
>> >
>> > 2. What are we expecting? Grains in general have subtle flavors, and
>> > millets are no exception. They bring notes and textures to a dish or
>> > confection, as well as bulk (esp. in high-starch diets), but aren't
>> there
>> > to dominate. Even bread, typically built around wheat flour, includes a
>> few
>> > or even many other ingredients - and then is eaten as a side or with a
>> > spread.
>> >
>> > 3. So what if they did have "no taste"? Who normally eats a grain
>> without
>> > accompaniment of some sort? Even if a millet is perceived as being
>> bland,
>> > I'd argue that the issue is what combinations work best with it. Food
>> > cultures of Asia and Africa may be well-established in this respect, but
>> > there is opportunity to experiment further everywhere - and that's the
>> key
>> > message I'd propose at this point.
>> >
>> > * WSJ, 20 Oct 2023
>> >
>> https://www.wsj.com/world/asia/supergrain-millet-healthy-india-modi-2cc8b9d4
>> >
>> >
>> > Don Osborn, PhD
>> > (East Lansing, MI, US)
>> > North American Millets Alliance
>> >
>> >
>> > --
>> > Collab mailing list
>> > Collab(a)lists.millets2023.space
>> > https://lists.millets2023.space/mailman/listinfo/collab
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> > This electronic message contains information generated by the USDA
>> solely
>> > for the intended recipients. Any unauthorized interception of this
>> message
>> > or the use or disclosure of the information it contains may violate the
>> law
>> > and subject the violator to civil or criminal penalties. If you believe
>> you
>> > have received this message in error, please notify the sender and delete
>> > the email immediately.
>> >
>>
2 years, 7 months
"Waxy" proso & FAO's closing event for IYM (was Re: Collab Digest, Vol 26, Issue 6)
by Don Osborn
Hi Joni, Gary, all.
Gary, thanks for the feedback on my critique of the WSJ article. Regarding
our own news source, we have the idea of a blog component for our missing
website (long story), which if handled well, could provide a lot of good
info - current issues, explainers, historic perspectives, and practical
info for those growing, processing, cooking, and eating millets. Some of
the posts on this list over the last couple of years might serve as gist
for articles right out of the gate. If we had the time and money, a podcast
on millets could highlight the work and stories of many people. No shortage
of material.
On FAO's closing event for IYM last Friday (3/29), I was too zonked to make
the 4:30 am (my time) opening, but did catch the last few talks (saw you on
the Zoom, Gary), as well as the final part (after they broke for lunch).
Nicely done, and as you note, it reflects well on the overall efforts on
the Year. These things are ambitious by definition - global observance,
with many potential "stakeholders," and reliance on local, national, and
regional initiatives. As we reflect, we will see areas that could have had
more attention, so hopefully the follow ups to the Year will take those
into account.
On the place(s) of millets in our diet in this part of the world, David and
Gary are right that "rice substitute" (or "rice plus" addition, per Joni's
initiative) is one obvious role. (Btw, could another substitution be in the
place of corn in grits?) However, I'm wondering how far substitution can
take us.
There used to be a commercial for a vegetable drink, "Wow, I coulda had a
V-8!" which implied that one could substitute V-8 for tomato juice or
another bottled/canned juice, but that appeal is limited. (Altho there was
a time I would sometimes go out of my way for their spicy version.) I think
they also marketed their product as a way of getting more veggies in one's
diet, which was a different appeal - differentiation.
So I wonder about differentiation in marketing millets. What ways can
millets be processed (healthily) and prepared that make them special?
Here's why we need taste testes and some well-funded and smart food
research.
Regarding waxy / sticky / glutinous proso, here's an additional idea.
Taking a page from the history of teff in the US, which originally was sold
overwhelmingly to Ethiopian restaurants and markets, could US-grown waxy
proso be packaged for the Chinese & East Asian food market in this country?
It's a modest market, occupied mainly by this variety of proso packaged in
China and imported. So the situation is a little different than that of
teff, which the main producer globally - Ethiopia - was not exporting for
some years. But maybe some possibilities, that could be researched?
Best to all,
Don
DO, EL, MI, US
NAMA
On Fri, Mar 29, 2024 at 12:27 PM Joni Kindwall-Moore <
joni(a)snacktivistfoods.com> wrote:
> Gary,
> Great thoughts!
> I have been in communication with Leon Kreisel who grows waxy Proso
> (thanks for connecting us Dr Santra).
> He has waxy Proso available right now, I would love to bring it to market
> but I literally can’t even get it hulled to do initial product dev on it
> due to the lack of processing. This remains the biggest barrier to growing
> domestic markets for diverse small cereals like millets thus preventing
> development of innovation.
> I’ve just secured a grant along with our partners at Zego foods and we
> will be installing millet processing to open up this bottleneck.
>
> https://snacktivistfoods.com/blogs/news/usda-awards-snacktivist-and-zego-3m…
>
> Waxy proso may also be a fantastic IQF grain to be mixed in with rice for
> foodservice etc.
> thanks
>
>
> *Joni Kindwall-Moore BSN-RN, BA*
> Founder, Innovator, Mother, Nurse, Activist
>
> *P: 406-334-1608* *www.snacktivistfoods.com
> <http://www.snacktivistfoods.com/>*
> *Scan this QR code to experience the Snacktivist Nation! *
>
>
>
> On Fri, Mar 29, 2024 at 8:23 AM Gary Wietgrefe via Collab <
> collab(a)lists.millets2023.space> wrote:
>
>> Don, I appreciated your reply to the WSJ. Ignoring the article would
>> confirm the premise.
>> As David suggested, millet is a rice alternative, just like bulgar wheat.
>> When millet reaches the U.S. food market share of bulgar wheat, millet
>> needs to step up to the share of pearl barley, rye (breads), oats (rolled,
>> meal, milk), then millet would be on its way to reaching the share of durum
>> wheat, and etcetera...just like other grains are trying to get to millet's
>> market share of wild birdfeed.
>> Today's closing ceremony of International Year of Millets proved
>> increased awareness of millets worldwide with speakers from Algeria,
>> Australia, and Minnesota, plus the expected substantial representation of
>> India and central Africa. It didn't just happen. India and the U.N. took
>> the lead highlighting millet uses through news media.
>> As suggested with waxy, someone, likely this group, needs to take the
>> lead with U.S. millet news articles. It is not enough to just respond when
>> some entity, as unlikely as the WSJ, randomly gives millet a bit of
>> recognition....Gary Wietgrefe
>>
>> On Fri, Mar 29, 2024 at 6:01 AM <collab-request(a)lists.millets2023.space>
>> wrote:
>>
>>> Send Collab mailing list submissions to
>>> collab(a)lists.millets2023.space
>>>
>>> To subscribe or unsubscribe via the World Wide Web, visit
>>> https://lists.millets2023.space/mailman/listinfo/collab
>>> or, via email, send a message with subject or body 'help' to
>>> collab-request(a)lists.millets2023.space
>>>
>>> You can reach the person managing the list at
>>> collab-owner(a)lists.millets2023.space
>>>
>>> When replying, please edit your Subject line so it is more specific
>>> than "Re: Contents of Collab digest..."
>>>
>>>
>>> Today's Topics:
>>>
>>> 1. Re: Reply to WSJ article on "millet" having "no taste"
>>> (Don Osborn)
>>>
>>>
>>> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
>>>
>>> Message: 1
>>> Date: Thu, 28 Mar 2024 09:06:41 -0400
>>> From: Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
>>> To: "Brenner, David (CTR) - REE-ARS" <david.brenner(a)usda.gov>
>>> Cc: Joni Kindwall-Moore <joni(a)snacktivistfoods.com>,
>>> "collab(a)lists.millets2023.space" <collab(a)lists.millets2023.space
>>> >
>>> Subject: Re: [Collab] Reply to WSJ article on "millet" having "no
>>> taste"
>>> Message-ID:
>>> <CA+RHibXPTUq=
>>> jwGGkyV9a3a2R1b2yS4xkmWJpkAAA21iXHuLqQ(a)mail.gmail.com>
>>> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
>>>
>>> Thank you for your replies,
>>>
>>> Joni, the article does seem to be an outlier, which is not to suggest
>>> that
>>> all coverage on millets has to be the same or uniformly positive. But
>>> here
>>> I get the sense that the object was to find some catchy juxtaposition
>>> (per
>>> clickbait, as you put it). It missed on some fundamentals, as I see it -
>>> namely: omission of mention of the International Year of Millets; no a
>>> clear indication that the authors understood that "millet" is not one
>>> thing, culinarily; and no delving into the premise of "no taste." A more
>>> productive angle, if they wanted to focus on the matter of flavors of
>>> millets, might have been to ask if taste might be a factor in the decline
>>> of popularity of millets relative to major cereal grains in India (since
>>> that country was the setting for the effort we are reviewing), and if it
>>> might be a factor in their revival. Not sure that would have worked
>>> either,
>>> but it might have been more thought provoking.
>>>
>>> This short feature article does not seem to have had much play in any
>>> media
>>> space, so it may not be helpful to write a formal reply. On the other
>>> hand,
>>> it might be worth cultivating relations with food writers at the WSJ and
>>> other news organizations. It's good that millets (even if just "millet")
>>> got some recognition in this paper - has it run any straight news pieces
>>> on
>>> millets or the IYM?. Maybe an invitation rather than a rebuttal would
>>> yield
>>> a better harvest?
>>>
>>> David, I actually have a waxy (glutinous [not glutEn as we know], or
>>> "sticky") proso millet in my kitchen. I've only used it as a grain
>>> component in a stew, with the thought that its physical qualities help
>>> make
>>> the sauce part more viscous (I'm more of a food hacker than a cook, but
>>> the
>>> resulta aren;t bad. My impression generally is that the flavor isn't
>>> significantly different. In the case of rice, for me, sticky rice is
>>> comfortably in the range of rice flavors. If you have a market
>>> specializing
>>> in Chinese foods, it should be easy to find sticky ("nuo") millets: proso
>>> ("da-hwang-mi") or foxtail ("xiao-mi").
>>>
>>> Regarding flavors of millets generally, I'd still like to see some
>>> "blind"
>>> taste tests. Is there enough of a millets constituency at Iowa State to
>>> arrange such a thing, say this fall?
>>>
>>> Best to all,
>>>
>>> Don
>>>
>>> DO, EL, MI, US
>>> NAMA
>>>
>>>
>>> On Mon, Mar 25, 2024 at 11:29?AM Brenner, David (CTR) - REE-ARS <
>>> david.brenner(a)usda.gov> wrote:
>>>
>>> > If this were a taste race with rice some millets could win placing near
>>> > bulgar wheat. I would like to enter waxy versions of millets in the
>>> same
>>> > race, but I have never tasted them, so I just guess they are wonderful.
>>> > Cooks make whole-plate compositions, as Don says. For example, we
>>> still
>>> > have vanilla ice cream even though chocolate ice cream and sherbert are
>>> > available. David Brenner
>>> >
>>> > ------------------------------
>>> > *From:* Collab <collab-bounces(a)lists.millets2023.space> on behalf of
>>> Joni
>>> > Kindwall-Moore <joni(a)snacktivistfoods.com>
>>> > *Sent:* Monday, March 25, 2024 9:30 AM
>>> > *To:* Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
>>> > *Cc:* collab(a)lists.millets2023.space <collab(a)lists.millets2023.space>
>>> > *Subject:* [External Email]Re: [Collab] Reply to WSJ article on
>>> "millet"
>>> > having "no taste"
>>> >
>>> > [External Email]
>>> > If this message comes from an *unexpected sender* or references a
>>> *vague/unexpected
>>> > topic;*
>>> > Use caution before clicking links or opening attachments.
>>> > Please send any concerns or suspicious messages to:
>>> Spam.Abuse(a)usda.gov
>>> > Yes, it was clear that it was just a 'click bait' silly article for the
>>> > reasons you mentioned above Don. What a wasted of journalism space. We
>>> > should write a rebuttal and approach the WSJ with it.
>>> >
>>> > On Sun, Mar 24, 2024 at 8:04?PM Don Osborn <don(a)milletsalliance.org>
>>> > wrote:
>>> >
>>> > Here is my reply to the Wall Street Journal article that characterised
>>> > "millet" as a "superfood" with "no taste." Thank you again to Prof.
>>> Dipak
>>> > Santra for enabling us to access the full article. Thanks also to Gary
>>> > Wietgrefe for his take on this issue, which I used in the third ("So
>>> > what?") question I raised. This was posted to LinkedIn on Friday
>>> 3/22. DO
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > The Wall Street Journal ran a feature article last fall that was less
>>> than
>>> > favorable about hashtag#millets from the perspective of hashtag#flavor
>>> -
>>> > "It?s the World?s Hot New Superfood. The Snag: It ?Has No Taste.?"*
>>> > Although the authors cover some useful points - and one is never upset
>>> to
>>> > see more discussion about millets - I'd like to engage with the
>>> premise of
>>> > "no taste." To do so I'll pose three questions: What are we talking
>>> about?
>>> > What are we expecting? & So what?
>>> >
>>> > First, however, wanted to express surprise that no reference was made
>>> in
>>> > the article to the larger context of Indian P.M. Narenda Modi's
>>> interest in
>>> > these grains, namely, the International Year of Millets (2023). How
>>> could
>>> > the authors and the WSJ editors fail to mention this observance, the
>>> > promotion of which has been a major project of P.M. Modi's government,
>>> and
>>> > which was ongoing at the time of publication?
>>> >
>>> > My three questions about the article's premise that millets have no
>>> taste,
>>> > and thoughts about them, follow:
>>> > 1. What are we talking about? The article is one of those which uses
>>> the
>>> > singular "millet" throughout, and this generally raises the question of
>>> > whether the authors are referring to (a) one specific kind of millet,
>>> being
>>> > unaware of other kinds, or rather (b) all kinds of millets, seen as
>>> having
>>> > the same characteristics. In this case, I'll assume that the authors
>>> (Shan
>>> > Li and Rajesh Roy) are aware of the plurality of millets, but for
>>> whatever
>>> > reason, treat them as so similar as to present as one thing in foods
>>> (b).
>>> >
>>> > In fact, millets are not the same. Personally I found this out years
>>> ago
>>> > when buying one "millet" thinking it was another, and finding out that
>>> the
>>> > taste was totally different. Today, some millets like proso and fonio
>>> are
>>> > described as having a slightly "nutty" flavor (this adjective is
>>> admittedly
>>> > overused), although I've also seen proso once compared to roasted corn
>>> (not
>>> > sure I'd agree, but it's clearly not without taste). Others, like
>>> little,
>>> > kodo, barnyard, are flatter in taste, closer to rice. One author
>>> described
>>> > finger millet as having a chocolatey flavor. Pearl millet has yet
>>> another
>>> > flavor, which I find unique.
>>> >
>>> > 2. What are we expecting? Grains in general have subtle flavors, and
>>> > millets are no exception. They bring notes and textures to a dish or
>>> > confection, as well as bulk (esp. in high-starch diets), but aren't
>>> there
>>> > to dominate. Even bread, typically built around wheat flour, includes
>>> a few
>>> > or even many other ingredients - and then is eaten as a side or with a
>>> > spread.
>>> >
>>> > 3. So what if they did have "no taste"? Who normally eats a grain
>>> without
>>> > accompaniment of some sort? Even if a millet is perceived as being
>>> bland,
>>> > I'd argue that the issue is what combinations work best with it. Food
>>> > cultures of Asia and Africa may be well-established in this respect,
>>> but
>>> > there is opportunity to experiment further everywhere - and that's the
>>> key
>>> > message I'd propose at this point.
>>> >
>>> > * WSJ, 20 Oct 2023
>>> >
>>> https://www.wsj.com/world/asia/supergrain-millet-healthy-india-modi-2cc8b9d4
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > Don Osborn, PhD
>>> > (East Lansing, MI, US)
>>> > North American Millets Alliance
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > --
>>> > Collab mailing list
>>> > Collab(a)lists.millets2023.space
>>> > https://lists.millets2023.space/mailman/listinfo/collab
>>> >
>>> >
>>> >
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > This electronic message contains information generated by the USDA
>>> solely
>>> > for the intended recipients. Any unauthorized interception of this
>>> message
>>> > or the use or disclosure of the information it contains may violate
>>> the law
>>> > and subject the violator to civil or criminal penalties. If you
>>> believe you
>>> > have received this message in error, please notify the sender and
>>> delete
>>> > the email immediately.
>>> >
>>>
2 years, 7 months